Javascript Disabled Detected

You currently have javascript disabled. Several functions may not work. Please re-enable javascript to access full functionality.

Submitter

Erhard Hermann
View other files from this member

Follow @BibleSupport

SUPPORT TOPIC File Information

Submitted: Apr 22 2021 08:18 AM
Last Updated: Jun 10 2025 03:50 PM
File Size: 2.4MB
Views: 2199
Downloads: 102
Author: Erhard Hermann
e-Sword Version: 9.x - 10.x
Suggest New Tag:: Judge, Judging

Support BibleSupport.com

Other Modules By Same Author

e-Sword 9+ Module Download:
Download To Judge or Not to Judge 1.0

Whole Bible Theology Biblical Studies Bible Interpretation

How do I view e-Sword Modules? Download the e-Sword Module Installer

Author:
Erhard Hermann

e-Sword Version:
9.x - 10.x

Suggest New Tag::
Judge, Judging

This module looks at the topic of judging and when it is appropriate and when it is not. It looks at who is to do the judging and how.

Contents
Introduction
Definitions
Old Testament Hebrew
New Testament Greek
Discernment
God is the ultimate judge
Governmental judging
Church judging

Passages related to not judging
Mat_7:1-5, Luk_6:37
Romans
Joh_7:24
James

Passages related to judging
Judging if it is right to help people
Judging sin in the church
Encouraging one another
Judging those outside the church
Judging false doctrines
Conclusion
Bibliography

Synopsis

"To Judge or Not to Judge" by Erhard Hermann explores the complex nature of human judgment, examining when it is appropriate to evaluate others and when restraint is necessary. The book delves into philosophical, psychological, and ethical considerations surrounding the act of judging, challenging readers to reflect on their own tendencies and the broader societal implications.

Hermann begins by dissecting the fundamental human inclination to form judgments. He argues that judging is an innate part of human cognition, essential for navigating social environments and making decisions. However, he emphasizes that this tendency can lead to biases, stereotypes, and unfair evaluations if left unchecked. The core question he poses is: when does judgment serve justice and understanding, and when does it foster prejudice and harm?

Throughout the book, Hermann explores various contexts in which judgment arises—personal relationships, legal systems, moral dilemmas, and cultural differences. He discusses how cultural norms influence what is judged and how those judgments can either promote social cohesion or cause division. For instance, the book examines cases where moral judgments are necessary to uphold societal values versus situations where prejudiced or superficial judgments undermine fairness.

A significant part of Hermann’s analysis is dedicated to the psychological mechanisms behind judgment. He investigates cognitive biases such as confirmation bias, stereotyping, and the fundamental attribution error, illustrating how these distort our perceptions and lead to unfair evaluations. Hermann advocates for increased self-awareness and mindfulness as tools to mitigate these biases, encouraging readers to question their initial impressions and seek deeper understanding before forming conclusions.

The author also explores the ethical dimensions of judging. He discusses the importance of context, intent, and compassion, arguing that judgments should be tempered with empathy and humility. Hermann advocates for a balanced approach—being cautious in passing judgment and recognizing the limits of one's understanding. He suggests that in many cases, withholding judgment can foster better relationships and promote social harmony.

Furthermore, Hermann considers the role of judgment in justice and morality. He examines philosophical perspectives from thinkers like Kant, Nietzsche, and Mill, comparing their views on moral evaluation. The book discusses the potential dangers of moral absolutism and the importance of moral relativism, urging readers to consider multiple perspectives before condemning or praising others.

In conclusion, "To Judge or Not to Judge" encourages a reflective approach to judgment—one that recognizes our natural tendencies but also strives for fairness, empathy, and humility. Hermann posits that judicious judgment, exercised thoughtfully, can serve as a tool for personal growth and social justice, whereas impulsive or biased judgments can cause harm. The book ultimately invites readers to develop a mindful attitude towards their evaluative tendencies, fostering a more compassionate and understanding society.

What's New in Version 1.0 (See full changelog)

06/10/25 Added Synopsis to Description, Uploaded refi module file

no debt men

May 04 2021 12:11 PM

I would suggest John 5:19 and especially verse 30, "I am able to do nothing from Myself; just as I hear, I judge; and My judgment is righteous, for I do not seek My will, but the will of the One sending Me, the Father." "as I hear," in my understanding relates to Romans 10:17, αρα^G686^THEREFOREη^G3588^THEπιστις^G4102^{FAITH "IS"} εξ^G1537^{OUT OF} ακοης^G189^HEARING^,η^G3588^BUT δε^G1161^THE ακοη^G189^HEARINGδια^G1223^THROUGH ρηματος^G4487^SPOKEN^WORD θεου^G2316^{OF GOD"}

R Which helps resolve Robertson's error and others who say, "Jesus is God, why would He need faith? Who would He believe in?" Showing that they don't understand what the Faith once delivered to the saint is. It is about hearing and obeying as in Romans 1:5 and 16:26: υπακοηνG5218^OBEDIENCEπιστεωςG4102^{OF FAITH}

And it is about who is your Father See John 8:43-44, esp verse 47: ο^G3588^{HE THAT}ων^G5607^BEINGεκ^G1537^OUTτου^G3588^OFθεου^G2316^GODτα^G3588^THE ρηματα^G4487^{SPOKEN WORDS}του^G3588^{OF THE} θεου^G2316^GODακουει^G191^H^EARS